Solution to the ménage problem



Next: Comparison with Kaplansky's Up: Non-sexist solution of the Previous: Solution to the

Solution to the ménage problem

For the ménage problem, we proceed just as before, only now we restrict the set of seatings to those where men and women alternate. The number of these seatings is : two ways to choose which seats are for men and which for women; ways to seat the men in the men's seats; ways to seat the women in the women's seats. Just as before, we have

where denotes the number of alternating seatings under which a specified set of couples all end up sitting together. This time we have

(Decide which are men's seats and which women's, where the couples go, which couple goes where, and where the men and women go.) Plugging in for yields

Plugging this expression for into the formula for above, we get

By symmetry, we know that must be divisible by . Pulling this factor out in front, we can write

The first few values of are shown in Table 2.

  
Table: Ménage numbers



Next: Comparison with Kaplansky's Up: Non-sexist solution of the Previous: Solution to the



Peter Doyle